Chapter II

The Cloud Chamber

Watching cosmic rays fall through a fish tank

CompleteJan 2023 – Feb 2023

Thin white streaks and short bright dashes on a dark background, lit from below.
Plate IIForty seconds of tracks, photographed at ISO 3200 through the side of the tank.

Every minute, a few hundred muons pass through your body. They are born twenty kilometres up, when cosmic rays slam into the atmosphere, and they arrive moving so fast that relativity is the only reason they survive the trip. You can’t feel them. But with a cold plate and some alcohol vapour, you can watch them.

This chapter is the story of building a chamber that does exactly that, and of the three weekends it took to get the first track.

The question

Can a chamber built from things in a hardware store show particle tracks clearly enough to tell one kind of particle from another?

The build

The design is simple: a black metal plate sits on dry ice at −78 °C, an upturned fish tank sits on the plate, and a strip of felt soaked in isopropyl alcohol lines the top of the tank. Alcohol evaporates at the warm top, sinks, cools, and hangs just above the plate as a layer of vapour that badly wants to condense.

Schematic plot of tracks per minute after sealing the lid
Tracks counted by eye each minute after sealing the lid. Activity peaks once the vapour layer forms, then falls off as the felt dries out.

The trick is getting that layer thick enough. Too warm and nothing condenses; too little alcohol and the layer is a millimetre thin.

Attempt Plate temperature Alcohol Result
1 −20 °C (ice + salt) 70% Nothing. Just fog.
2 −78 °C (dry ice) 70% Faint mist, no tracks
3 −78 °C (dry ice) 99% Tracks within 4 minutes

What appeared

Once the vapour layer formed, tracks began to appear, a few each second, each lasting about a second before it sank and faded.


What I learned

The physics was the easy part. The engineering was all about temperature gradients and keeping the inside of the tank still: every draft destroyed the layer.

If I build another, I would add a Peltier stack instead of dry ice so it can run for hours, and a small radioactive source (a thoriated welding rod) to have something to point at.